My husband and I had a truly wonderful time at the Island City House (and we're both pretty picky.) Our suite in the Cigar House was not extravagant, but clean and spacious. The staff did not have exhaustive knowledge (e.g. they did not have a bus schedule for me to look at) but they were very kind and genuinely friendly.... more

My boyfriend & I recently stayed at the Island City House Hotel for 3 nights and had a wonderful experience. Since we arrived after the office closed, the management left our key in an envelope for us at the front office. We stayed in the Arch House studio suite on the 2nd floor. It had a comfortable bed, nice bathroom... more

My husband and I stayed for 4 nights at The Island City House. We made an excellent choice...Our 3rd floor room in the Cigar House was perfect, roomy and very comfortable with pleasant decor. The kitchen/living area was equipped with everything needed to settle right in and the balcony overlooking the pool was a relaxing place to be. Breakfast each... more

We stayed for 2 nights in the ICH 2 bedroom suite and the room was wonderful. Granite work tops, lovely wooden furniture and really clean. The private porch was lovely to relax on after walking about all day. It was really hot and so the pool was lovely for cooling off. The breakfast was really nice in the courtyard setting... more

Can not say enough about this hotel. From the moment we arrived we loved it. The rooms are great and the we loved having the private porch. The staff was very friendly and helpful. Pool was great as well. This is one of the most romantic hotels I have ever stayed in. If you are looking for a place to... more

My husband and I got married in May in Key West. We stayed at Island City House for 6 days. We were in the Island City building as well as another family that were with us. The location is great. It is quiet on William Street, and just a short walk to the seaport. The staff was great. With all... more

What a great find! The Island City House staff was very welcoming and our suite was wonderful. We stayed in the cigar house, with a full kitchen and balcony deck. The bed was comfortable and breakfast in the garden was great. We rented bicycles from the hotel and toured Key West--the only way to go! We were not able to... more

Stayed here for 1 night and it was amazing! Full kitchen, living room, full bath with tub, bathroom with a full size closet and 2 flat screen TVs. The place was very well designed and tastefully decorated. We found no faults in this establishment and will stay here the next time we visit Key West. Also comes with Continental Breakfast.... more

We stayed here on the weekend of the April 26, 2008. We were instantly impressed when we walked in to the suite. It was huge! There were 2 flat screen tv's and it was immaculate. The daily breakfast was good and the staff was VERY friendly. We personally did not have any issues with parking. We highly recommend this B+B. more